Published work
Read the argument, then take it apart.
Everything here is released for comment. Objections — legal, historical, philosophical or empirical — are more useful than agreement.
Each entry has a one-page brief you can read here. The full paper is sent on request, so that it can go to a reader with the question in view. Work under submission to journals is not listed.
Essays and papers
One page now; the paper on request.
SE-03 · Article
Purpose, oath, and the republic that may not be consecrated
The Preamble states what the government is for, the oath states what officers swear to, and the Constitution refuses to say what any citizen must profess. One design: a purpose statement is as confining as a rights statement.
Read the brief →
Request the full paper
SE-04 · Essay
Why the Semperists were right
The men called Anti-Federalists were not against the Constitution. They were against trusting structure to hold without written prohibitions. Madison came to agree, and wrote the cage himself.
Read the brief →
Request the full paper
SE-05 · Working draft
Marriage as incorporation
The state has two powers over domestic life: to enforce obligations and to define relationships. It should keep the first and give up the second. Churches keep marriage; the state registers what people actually undertake.
Read the brief →
Request the full paper
SE-06 · Essay
AI eschatology as a jurisdictional maneuver
Whether it promises extinction or paradise, AI eschatology works as a forum-selection clause. It moves authority up to summits and licensing boards, and away from the ordinary law states and county courts already enforce.
Read the brief →
Request the full paper
SE-01 · Essay
A Semperist reading of the European Return Regulation
Europe’s return debate asks who must leave. It does not ask who owes for the displacement in the first place. The receiving state has already answered that question in its own recognition decisions, and the answer names a regime.
Read the brief →
Request the full paper
SE-02 · Outline
When institutions may penalise lawful private conduct
Smoking, cannabis, motorcycles, firearms: employers, insurers, civil services and the military each treat lawful risk-taking differently, and no one designed the pattern. A test for when an institution may reach conduct the law permits.
Read the brief →
Request the full paper
Why the full papers are sent rather than posted
Several of these papers are still moving, and some are written for a particular audience or jurisdiction. Rather than post a version written for nobody in particular, I send the current one with the question in view. Say what you are working on in the request and I will reply with the paper, usually within a few days. Requests are as welcome from critics as from allies.
Not everything is listed here
Further work — on the Constitution, the Pledge and the oath, and scripture — is under submission to journals and so is not posted. It is available on request for review purposes. Write to shknudson@semperism.org.